The Hidden Cost of ₹5,000: Advocate Narayana Swamy G on How Students Become Unwitting Cybercrime Conduits
Beyond the Scam: Why India’s Legal System is Struggling to Contain the Cybercrime Wave In an era dominated by digital transactions, cybercrime is rapidly evolving, often targeting the most vulnerable. The cynical use of young college students as “mules” for illicit money transfers and the systemic challenges faced by law enforcement. The High-Risk “Mule Account” Scam One of the most concerning scams detailed involves the manipulation of college students for financial fraud. This scheme turns young, naive individuals into criminals without their full knowledge, often for a meager sum. The Lure of Easy Money: Scammers approach college students, offering them a small amount of money, typically ₹5,000 to ₹10,000, as pocket money. The Documentation Trap: In exchange for this sum, the students are asked to provide their Aadhaar Card and PAN Card to open a new bank account in their name. The Execution of Fraud: The scammers then take complete control of this new account. They use it as a “mule account,” transferring money that has been fraudulently obtained from other victims (e.g., through online scams or after freezing legitimate accounts). The Devastating Consequence: After the scammed money (often in lakhs) is deposited and withdrawn by the fraudsters, the original victims file FIRs. Since the account is legally in the student’s name, the FIR and subsequent legal action are filed against the college student, who then faces the risk of jail time. The student remains legally liable because the account is in their name, even if they only received a small fraction of the money. Other Emerging Digital Threats The discussion also briefly touched upon other forms of digital criminal activity: Job Offer Extortion: Fraudsters promising jobs trick victims into creating explicit content which is then screen-recorded and used for blackmail and extortion. Stolen Phone Scams: Thieves steal mobile phones and use them to intercept OTPs or conduct other financial scams, often targeting vulnerable and less tech-savvy individuals in rural areas who do not know the immediate steps to take after losing their phone. The Systemic Failures in Combating Cybercrime The founder of Jaitra Associates, Advocate Narayanaswamy G, highlighted several issues within the enforcement and judicial systems that allow cybercrime to flourish: Inadequate Police Training and Resources: The current police system is not sufficiently equipped to investigate complex cybercrime. Lawyer Narayanaswamy G notes that the system lacks the necessary training, technology, and facility resources to effectively counter and solve these sophisticated crimes. More focus on in-depth training for the police is crucial. Judicial Overload: Dedicated courts for cybercrime matters, such as those handling account freezing/defreezing requests, are already struggling. They are currently overwhelmed, dealing with an estimated 500 to 600 cases per day. A Need for Specialization: Advocate Narayanaswamy G says that the prediction is clear, in the future, cybercrime will become the highest form of crime, dominating legal dockets. The current infrastructure will not suffice, and the need for five or six times the current number of specialized cybercrime courts will soon become a reality. Stay Alert and Protect Your Identity Advocate Narayanaswamy G conveys that the rapid rise of digital fraud necessitates extreme caution. The greatest defense against falling victim to these evolving scams is awareness. Never share personal documents like Aadhaar or PAN cards for “easy money” schemes, as the legal and personal costs far outweigh any temporary financial gain. As the system works to catch up to the pace of cyber criminals, personal vigilance remains the strongest shield. https://youtu.be/bfPR1BVhr0o?si=xWCAxBTiCSYs-jo9